The Real Difference Between Home Health Aides and Personal Care Assistants

After discovering that your elderly parent needs assistance at home, you are suddenly tossed into a world of confusing job titles including home health aide, personal care assistant, caregiver, and companion. What’s the difference? This is more than a question of semantics. There are real differences that will matter in terms of the services provided and what you have to pay.

It’s understandable that you might be confused. Both of these types of workers come to someone’s home to assist them. Both may help them bathe and/or feed them. However, the training, scope of practice and payment all differ. Getting it wrong could mean that you end up paying for services that could be covered by insurance or hiring someone who is not legally allowed to provide the care your loved one needs.

What Home Health Aides Actually Do

Home health aides provide personal care and companionship, but they do it under the supervision of a nurse or other medical professional. That’s the first major difference between them and a personal care assistant (PCA). Home health aides have been trained to provide clinical care. They can take vital signs, assist with prescribed exercise programs, adhere to complex medication regimens and even monitor chronic medical conditions.

The training is also much more rigorous and standardized. Most states require at least 75 hours of training, including practical experience, and competency testing. Home health aides learn topics such as basic anatomy and physiology, infection control, body mechanics for assisting patients with transfers, and how to recognize when a patient may be deteriorating.

This is where it becomes essential: aides generally work as part of a formalized plan of care that has been authorized by a medical professional. If your mother or father has just been discharged from the hospital after a surgical procedure, or if he or she has diabetes or heart disease being managed at home, a home health aide is likely what the doctor will prescribe. These plans can be covered by Medicare Part A or B, and that means that insurance will cover costs for a limited time.

The oversight is not episodic. A nurse supervisor checks in regularly, reviews the plan of care, and ensures that all home health aides are following the same orders. This provides peace of mind to family caregivers while also meaning that there is likely less flexibility in terms of schedule and duties.

Personal Care Assistants Take a Different Approach

Personal care assistants (also known as PCAs or home care aides; just to make this confusing) focus on helping individuals with activities of daily living. They will bathe them, dress them, and groom them. They will help them use the toilet, prepare their meals, keep their space clean, and provide companionship by visiting or taking them on outings.

They will not, however, administer medications, provide medical care or “treat” clients in any way. Training tends to vary from state to state. Some states require PCAs to complete a certification program. Others only require background checks and orientation to the policies of the agency employing them. This doesn’t mean that PCA workers are any less skilled at their jobs, they often have years of experience and deep knowledge about how to help people retain their dignity and independence. This just means they are neither trained nor permitted to provide any medical assistance to clients.

For families in need of assistance like this, services like Home Care Erie PA can help connect the level of care required with an appropriate caregiver who can provide the services needed.

These services are not usually covered by Medicare because personal care assistance is defined as “custodial care” rather than health care. This semantic distinction is painful for families who spend thousands of dollars a month on what they consider essential services. Some Medicaid programs cover PCA services and some long-term care insurance policies do, but many families are paying privately.

Flexibility is often better with PCAs. Families can often work out schedules more easily without the need for medical oversight. Family caregivers can arrange hours as needed, add or remove hours as needed (especially for things like doctor’s appointments or physical therapy appointments) and what the PCA does can be tailored to what the individual needs each day. The PCA often becomes part of a household routine rather than a medical intervention.

When Care is Just About Medical Needs

The practical question is not what to call these workers, but what kind of help your parent requires at this moment. If someone has just had a stroke and needs assistance with physical therapy exercises; practice; and the monitoring of complications or changes in condition, this is home health aide territory. If someone is physically stable but cannot take a bath or eat without someone else’s assistance, then a PCA should be more than sufficient.

In theory anyway, these situations can sometimes be messy. Your dad may have needed home health aide intervention after coming home from the hospital but once he has stabilized then he may just need PCA assistance to help him take a bath and feed him.

In some instances, people may need both. A home health aide may come three days a week to administer medications and check blood glucose levels while a PCA comes every day to help him take a bath and prepare his meals. This could get expensive if insurance is not involved but might be the best option in messy real-life situations.

The Cost Reality Nobody Enjoys

Home health aide services run more expensive, usually about $25 to $35 or more per hour depending on where you live and what kind of skilled assistance is needed. When Medicare covers these costs, it’s great. When Medicare is not involved, these costs can be daunting.

For families paying privately, personal care assistants cost around $20-$28 per hour. It’s still not cheap but the somewhat lower range may make these services more feasible for families who have to pay out of pocket. In some instances, parents can hire PCAs for longer shifts at lower costs than paying for brief visits from skilled nurses.

Families should not overlook the financial toll caring for an elderly parent at home can create. Most families do not think about how much each month will cost in cases where personal care assistants or home health aides are hired. Understanding the difference between job duties also helps families avoid paying skilled nursing rates for help that does not actually need this level of intervention.

How Do You Know What Type of Care You Need?

The first thing to do is ask yourself (and your parent if it’s appropriate) what kind of care they need on a daily basis? Are there medically related tasks that require assistance? Does their doctor believe they would benefit from skilled nursing assistance while living in the community? Do they have complications in their medical history that would require more specialized assistance? If so, all of this points toward needing home health aide services rather than simple PCA assistance.

If someone only needs help with safety, nutrition, hygiene and companionship rather than actually addressing medical issues then PCA assistance should be more than sufficient. Many elderly individuals fall into this latter category; while they may not need medical assistance they do need someone else to help keep them safe at home.

The best thing family caregivers can do is touch base with their elderly family member’s primary care physician (it doesn’t have to be every time but it should be an occasional event). Ask if they believe the elderly parent needs skilled nursing interventions or if they believe that personal care assistance would be sufficient for what is being proposed to keep the elderly parent safe at home. Request something in writing that can be presented to the insurance company in case they try to deny coverage.

Then, ask around about what services are available in your area because not all home care agencies offer both PCA and home health aide services; some only provide home health aide interventions while others only provide PCA care. Understanding what kind of care you actually need before you start calling can make the process less overwhelming.

Parsing through the differences between home health aides and personal care assistants can seem like busy work when families are just trying to keep an elderly parent safe at home. However, understanding what these two types of workers provide and what the cost can help families decide which type of worker is needed at this point in time.

In some cases, people may need skilled nursing interventions while in other instances they may just need someone to assist them with basic activities of daily living tasks. Both types of workers provide essential assistance in different and profound ways so assess the situation before it’s too late.

Comments are closed.